Main Menu
Grumpy's BBQ Sauce
Jersey Boyz Jerky
search

Pepper Pictures
March 2010
S M T W T F S
« Oct    
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031  
Sweet Sunshine Sauces
Syndicate
RSS 2.0
Comments RSS 2.0



Add to Google



Enter your Email


Powered by FeedBlitz
Danny Cash Hot Sauces
Recent Comments
  • DEFCON Creator - Agreed.…
  • Scott Roberts - I wish this thing would be turned back on...…
  • Buddah - [Comment ID #551090 Quote] Thak, come join the new HSB, this…
  • thakswet - This stuff is so good. SO GOOD. every…
  • The truth - You really should worry about your site instead of coming…
  • The truth - Yea dead as that...lol…
  • Leroy - [Comment ID #519830 Quote] That neat you can taste your on…
  • The truth - its almost as dead in here as taste my ass…
Csigi Chili Sauce
Subscribe to the Fiery Foods Magazine!
Review: Batten Island Mild Gourmet Sauce
Posted on 09.11.07 by Louie @ 8:20 pm | Comments: |
« « Previous | “I Like It HOT!” Festival » »

Batten Island Gourmet Sauce

Is “FLSauce” the company who makes this? Or is Batten Island the company?

Ingredients: Raisins and/or dates & prunes, vinegar, apple, (one or more of the following: pears, papaya, mango), Habanero & Cayenne pepper, tomato paste, brown sugar, garlic, onion, salt, and other exotic herbs & spices.

After learning my lesson from a certain fruit-based hot sauce not to judge a sauce by its ingredient list, I went ahead and tore the cape off of this one. It was disgusting. Not only was the bottle mucked up (which in all fairness does happen sometimes), the smell emanating from it was just, frankly, putrid. So I read the ingredients list again. Now, at the store, any time I see “and/or”, or worse “one or more of the following” I put that product right down (I have kids, so reading labels is a force of habit). “And/or”? “One or more of the following”?

Question #1 before I continue: Why couldn’t someone decide what the hell was going into this?

Question #2 before I continue: How much longer will I go on before this review turns into a mad rant?

Batten Island Gourmet Sauce

But I digress. I poured the sauce onto a plate, well, really I shook the heck out of it, and it fell out in a big “glop”. I thought to myself how this wasn’t going well already, and walked away. A couple minutes later my six year old stepson asked me (I swear to God I’m not making this up) “Why is there cat poop on the counter?”. To make matters worse, I eventually got the courage to actually try the stuff, and…I have no idea what it was I was tasting. Was it raisins and/or dates? Or was it one or more of the pears, papaya or mango? It sure wasn’t habanero or cayenne (my two year old daughter licked my trusty tasting spoon clean). Or was it “other exotic herbs and spices? And by the way, what if I’m allergic to those “other” exotic herbs and spices? All I could taste was a pasty, some kind of fruit mix (like a fruit roll). Mild sauce? Gourmet sauce??

Batten Island Gourmet Sauce

Ok, here comes the rant. This was labeled as a “mild” sauce. Doesn’t there have to be some kind, any kind, of heat source? The ingredients list clearly says there’s habanero and cayenne. Where? I should point out that the ingredients list is printed in the smallest font on the whole label, and on the side of the bottle, in bold black letters, it reads “MIGHT AS WELL HAVE THE BEST” Well honey, it ain’t coming from this bottle. I really have no idea what these people were thinking when they constructed this sauce. At first I thought maybe I got a tainted bottle (it happens), but after tasting it multiple times, I knew this is what they were going for (and yes, I have consumed tainted hot sauces).

You know, I’m all for a free economy, where anyone can sell anything. But has the hot sauce industry come to a point where anyone can just pump something out without market testing it first? And what was the consumer market this bottle was targeted at?

So here I am, making the call out to all of the producers that give a rat’s ass about hot sauce, that actually take the patient time and care required to produce a quality product. Italy and France have laws (laws!) about what can or cannot be labeled as a quality wine, and cheese. The California olive oil industry has very strict codes as far as quality in labels, also. Shouldn’t we, in our industry, recognize that hot sauce is not just “sauce”, but its own viable ingredient, a food itself? I sell my own brand (Old Skool Pyrate) around Wisconsin, a pure habanero blend, and the first question I’m asked is-you guessed it-“Is it hot?”. You all have been asked that question, how many times? No, I am not implying that we need to educate the public about quality sauces, I’m saying that its because of “gourmet” sauces like this one that people don’t know what quality is. There needs to be something, dare I say a governing body, that regulates what is good sauce, and what is really great sauce, decided on by ingredients, handling, and production. Maybe there already is something like the D.O.C.G., or the A.O.C. (Italy and France), or the California Olive Oil Council. I don’t know. I’m just tired of seeing slop like this on the market.

So here’s my Five Points Scale:
Appearance: 0. Read again what my step son asked.
Smell: 0. I have no idea what I was supposed to be smelling in the first place. Raisins and/or what?
Taste: 0. Again, I don’t know what I was supposed to be tasting, since I don’t know what the hell is in this.
Heat:0. Do I really need to go on?

I always end by saying to treat every meal like it was your last. Don’t do it with this sauce.

Batten Island Gourmet Sauce
10418 New Berlin Road Suite 224
Jacksonville, Fl 32226
1-877-FLSauce


Chilehead Comments:
Posted by: Louie - Categories: Uncategorized
Permalink: Review: Batten Island Mild Gourmet Sauce

One year ago: Three Hot Tamales - Toxic Tonic Review
Two years ago: Houston Hot Sauce Festival Coming Up

48 Comments »

Comment #1:
Comment by Fat Kid Sauces (282) - 9/11/2007 @ 8:37 pm | [ Quote ]

Now thats a great review…… LOL Cat poop - still laughing…. kids are great.

Comment #2:
Comment by Scott (593) - 9/11/2007 @ 9:17 pm | [ Quote ]

I live about 10 miles from that place. Should I go there and slap the hell out of them. :)

Comment #3:
Comment by DK (2470) - 9/11/2007 @ 10:10 pm | [ Quote ]

Cool, it’s gotta gator on the label!! :D

Comment #4:
Comment by DK (2470) - 9/11/2007 @ 10:12 pm | [ Quote ]

Maybe it was gotor poop. 8O

Of course the only gator I ever saw with the runs was runnin’ from Leroy! ;)

Poor Gator! :lol:

Comment #5:
Comment by thakswet (531) - 9/11/2007 @ 10:13 pm | [ Quote ]

great review.

Comment #6:
Comment by DK (2470) - 9/11/2007 @ 10:13 pm | [ Quote ]

gator poop. sorry. :(

Comment #7:
Comment by Justin (159) - 9/11/2007 @ 11:23 pm | [ Quote ]

i reviewed the hot version of this sauce but it hasnt been posted yet, i dont mean to ruin the suprise but it only got a 2.5 out of 10 for the overall rating i gave it, it sounds like it was just slightly better than the medium and the best thing about the sauce was the cool label. im not a gator luver or nothing but the labels nice.

Comment #8:
Comment by Sam - 9/12/2007 @ 10:12 am | [ Quote ]

I hate to see a sauce tank, but way to tell it like it is!!

Comment #9:
Comment by Scott (593) - 9/12/2007 @ 11:28 am | [ Quote ]

Is gotor poop a mix between gator and Cooter poo??

Comment #10:
Comment by DK (2470) - 9/12/2007 @ 11:49 am | [ Quote ]

So you’ve seen the mythical Swamp Cooter too? Must be a bunch of ‘em down there in you’re parts, they’re a rare sight around here. Sometimes people confuse cooter poo with gator poo, so a mix would be hard to discern and could possibly be mistaken for kitty poo. Hmmmm. ;)

Comment #11:
Comment by Tina Brooks (101) - 9/12/2007 @ 4:05 pm | [ Quote ]

I need stitches! LMFAO!!!

That maybe the best damned review of the worst damned hot sauce I’ve ever seen!

lol

Comment #12:
Comment by Gildo (385) - 9/12/2007 @ 5:31 pm | [ Quote ]

I’m crying here. Funniest review I’ve read on the blog so far. I dare the MFG to post a rebuttle.

Comment #13:
Pingback by The Hot Zone Online » Damn That’s Funny or Damn That’s Sad… You Choose! - 9/12/2007 @ 5:41 pm | [ Quote ]

[...] Click here to read the entire review. [...]

Comment #14:
Comment by Tina Brooks (101) - 9/12/2007 @ 5:49 pm | [ Quote ]

I blogged on your blog, Louie. You can read it here.

Thanks for the laugh.

Comment #15:
Comment by Tina Brooks (101) - 9/12/2007 @ 5:51 pm | [ Quote ]

Erp… I guess with pingback I don’t have to tell you I blogged you. lol

Comment #16:
Comment by The Guy that makes Batten Island Gourmet Sauce (1) - 9/12/2007 @ 5:59 pm | [ Quote ]

Well you know….I was cleaning out the cat litter while making a batch of sauce one day and the phone rang and I turned to toss the poop into the garbage can…..although the steam kettle looks a lot like the garbage can….and they’re right beside each other……….so maybe I………nah…..that couldn’t be……….could it??

Comment #17:
Comment by Arizona Jack (1284) - 9/12/2007 @ 8:33 pm | [ Quote ]

WOW !!!!!! speechless here !! Excellent review of a not so excellent sauce, LMAO

Comment #18:
Comment by Devil Duck (68) - 9/13/2007 @ 1:11 am | [ Quote ]

You know…. I don’t comment here all that much, but I did rant a little while ago about how there seem to be an abundance of “sauces” on the market that are crap, but catch the average consumer with a catchy (sometimes X rated) name with claims of quality.

Now, we all know that crap comes in a lot of different forms. But, I must say that I agree on starting some sort of committee that will guarantee the consumer some sort of minimal standard for quality. Misrepresentation of a product is a crime in any other industry.

Comment #19:
Comment by Jim- StepUpForCharity.org (1537) - 9/13/2007 @ 6:20 am | [ Quote ]

Devil Duck on 9/13/2007 at 1:11 am said:

You know…. I don’t comment here all that much, but I did rant a little while ago about how there seem to be an abundance of “sauces” on the market that are crap, but catch the average consumer with a catchy (sometimes X rated) name with claims of quality.

Now, we all know that crap comes in a lot of different forms. But, I must say that I agree on starting some sort of committee that will guarantee the consumer some sort of minimal standard for quality. Misrepresentation of a product is a crime in any other industry.

Absolutely nuts, in my opinion, that anyone would want the government to put their hands into this, even more than they already have! “Quality” is a matter of taste and everyone has a different opinion. Look at the number of folks that hate chipotle- I’d sure not want one of them sitting on a board telling me my sauce doesn’t meet the “standard” ’cause they hate chipotle. Look at how we as a blog pan the marginally flavored vinegars like Tabasco & Franks, yet they are among the top sellers. Look at how we get on out high horse about this ingredient or that, and yet El Yuc with both artificial colors and preservatives is always rated high among favorites! FREE MARKET will solve most/all ills, along with some education. A review of the sauce goes a long way to that education. If the stuff is truly crap, then sales will reflect that. I’m willing to bet though, that you could give this sauce out to 10 people and at least a few of them would have a radically different opinion of it. How does the opinion of he that hates it, trump the one that loves it? Again- it’s all a matter of individual TASTE. I respect the views of the reviewer- he obviously didn’t like it and clearly stated why- thank you for that! I’ve had a sauce or two of mine panned because it didn’t meet that person’s opinion of what it should be. They were in the strict minority though, and a thick skin is part and parcel to belonging to an industry that deals with the public- you can’t please everyone! If Batten Island is truly that bad, it won’t exist long on the marketplace and will fix itself without some beaurocrat adding more arcane regulations. It ain’t gonna poison anyone and beyond that, it’s simply “opinion”.

For cripes sake, the gov has already made enough of a mess of food regulations and you want them to start regulating “taste”?! Let’s think about that one for a moment.

Comment #20:
Comment by DK (2470) - 9/13/2007 @ 6:34 am | [ Quote ]

Well said Jim.

If Batten Island is truly that bad, it won’t exist long on the marketplace

I’ve got a few bottles of Batten Island on my shelf of gator themed bottles that I know are from at least late ’90’s or no later than ‘01, so they’re not a new company. They must be doing something right somewhere, and someone obviously enjoys their sauce. I’m almost at the point of enough curiosity to buy the one reviewed here just to see how “bad” it really is! LOL!!! To be honest, there’s only a couple of sauces I’ve ever tossed for not liking the flavor.

Yes, I have a shelf of gator themed sauces! LOL!!

Comment #21:
Comment by Devil Duck (68) - 9/13/2007 @ 6:50 am | [ Quote ]

Ok…I agree with the “keep the government out” stand. As a matter of fact, I couldn’t agree more.

I’m talking about an independent board that consists of a panel of sauce makers, that recognizes quality products. Lots of us may “hate” Tobasco sauce, but that doesn’t mean that it isn’t a quality product.

I know that the small sauce businesses are paying fees out the wazoo already (one reason I’m not pro yet) but, for a few extra bucks, they can display a logo of sorts (as small as possible) that their sauce has passed an independent panel review on quality. Now, I know already that there would be problems with that… The panel would get backed up with product for review, etc., etc… But this would have to be a pretty big entity in order to succeed. Could you accomplish this without the government stepping in? Yes, but the panel would have to be regulated somehow. We are dealing with the FDA and all…

Yes, we have industry awards…but does Joe Consumer really know anything about them? What about the sauces that are really good sauces and didn’t earn a “Golden Chili” or a “Scovie”?

Comment #22:
Comment by HenryK (217) - 9/13/2007 @ 9:44 am | [ Quote ]

Devil Duck on 9/13/2007 at 6:50 am said:

Ok…I agree with the “keep the government out” stand. As a matter of fact, I couldn’t agree more.

I’m talking about an independent board that consists of a panel of sauce makers, that recognizes quality products. Lots of us may “hate” Tobasco sauce, but that doesn’t mean that it isn’t a quality product.

I know that the small sauce businesses are paying fees out the wazoo already (one reason I’m not pro yet) but, for a few extra bucks, they can display a logo of sorts (as small as possible) that their sauce has passed an independent panel review on quality. Now, I know already that there would be problems with that… The panel would get backed up with product for review, etc., etc… But this would have to be a pretty big entity in order to succeed. Could you accomplish this without the government stepping in? Yes, but the panel would have to be regulated somehow. We are dealing with the FDA and all…

Yes, we have industry awards…but does Joe Consumer really know anything about them? What about the sauces that are really good sauces and didn’t earn a “Golden Chili” or a “Scovie”?

Why don’t you do as Jim said, let go of it!!!! OPINIONS everyone has them and yours is sick.

I am a consumer and I will not be told what I should like or dislike, if it has been approved by FDA and Etc what in the world can your narrow mind offer to a board that has no control of ANYTHING!!!! You will make
a good government official.

I guess you like fried chicken and eat it with skin on to get that extra taste.. I hate the skin and the extra FAT— should we get a committee together and make me like skin or should I form a committee to make you like it without the skin. SOUNDS STUPID–DOESN’T IT?????

I know what I like and can read what is on a label. I have my own taste likes and dislikes. I DO NOT NEED THE LIKES OF YOURSELF WHO THINKS YOU CAN BECOME THE CONTROL.

I think that using the word BBQ and all variations should only be used to discribe the torn up pile of meat that is the aftermath of smoking a PorkButt/Shoulder/Picinic until it reaches 190º. That will never happen so accept it!!! Do you get my message??????

Not one person suggested that the bottle of sauce may have been cracked opened by someone and than the sauce can only spoil after
that. Maybe that is why all the PooP.

Hi all, Have a good day

Comment #23:
Comment by Sam - 9/13/2007 @ 9:47 am | [ Quote ]

Okay, first I totally agree with Jim no Gov, I also think that DD may have a good idea. It is at least worth discussion.

Comment #24:
Comment by parker394 (622) - 9/13/2007 @ 10:07 am | [ Quote ]

Funny stuff….lol

Comment #25:
Comment by Tina Brooks (101) - 9/13/2007 @ 10:45 am | [ Quote ]

Let’s not get crazy about this whole thing… when I blogged that maybe we needed a governing board for hot sauces, I was joking. And, I’m pretty certain that Louie was too. He and I are both well aware, as makers, that not every person on the planet is going to like your sauce, and as DK pointed out, Batten’s been around a long time already, not everyone is going to react as strongly as Louie did!

That said… Independent review boards exist. They are called Guilds or customers or Scovies or Golden Chile Awards, etc.

We belong to several juried craft guilds, but we haven’t ever won a scovie or a golden chile, of course, that is primarily because you have to actually enter the contests to win. Truth be told, though, all of these “standards” are already in place.

Maybe we SHOULD have a Makers’s Guild. But then, we’d have to form one and run it and frankly, with all that I have to do, setting up and running another Guild just isn’t in my time schedule.

DD, maybe you have time to organize such a thing? We would participate. But, it would be a Guild of peers and the idea would be to ensure that we were all competing on a level playing field; not deciding for anyone’s customers whether or not the sauces tasted good. So… assuming Batten followed all the rules the rest of us follow, this sauce would probably get approved.

Louie didn’t like this sauce… maybe he doesn’t like dates? Who knows. Perhaps he’d like the other sauces that Batten makes? I don’t know. What I do know is that we make 22 different sauces under the Peppermaster label and the reason that we make THAT many sauces is because everyone’s tastes are different.

As for the FDA approving things… Here’s a few facts not in evidence for you about our beloved FDA… (don’t get me started). The FDA doesn’t “approve” anything. What they do is put a bunch of paperwork and fees in your way and expect you to comply with that. Then they randomly pull your product off the shelf or at the border (for importers) and only THEN do they even look at your products. Pity the fool who isn’t in compliance with the paperwork, the FDA gets weird. But that’s a blog waiting to happen (trust me on that).

What we as makers would like to see is legal labels, proper nutritionals etc. What we don’t want to see is jars of Mrs. Jones’ homemade apple habanero jelly made in her unsanitary home kitchen sitting on the shelf next to ours pretending it was made in an approved kitchen.

Whether or not a sauce tastes good is too varied a rule, I think, to apply to something to say whether or not it is “quality”.

Here in Canada, if peanuts are processed in any way in the same building as our sauces we would have to put “may contain nuts” on our labels. Perhaps the fact that Batten’s production does several sauces simultaneously explains the may contain this or that ingredients list? Maybe it doesn’t maybe he varies whichever of those fruit happen to be in season and unlike us (who print our labels per batch) prints his labels in batches of 5000 at a time? Who knows.

What I do know is that as funny as the review is, and as interesting as the idea of a guild is, let’s not shoot the foot of the maker, just because Louie didn’t like the sauce.

And God Forbid… Let’s not have anything more to do with the FDA or Government regulations than we already have… I mean reeeeeally!

And lets hope, that if I ever get a review from someone who doesn’t like my sauce that the writer of that review has the temerity to make it at least half as funny as this review.

T

Comment #26:
Comment by Jim- StepUpForCharity.org (1537) - 9/13/2007 @ 11:33 am | [ Quote ]

I see your point DD, but as the say- the devil is in the duck… er I mean details ;-)

The problem comes in the make up of the review board. If it’s fellow manufacturers, that’s a *real* problem. There are already a few blog manufacturers that don’t agree with the idea of fellow manufacturers reviewing other manufacturers stuff- it can hardly be considered unbiased and can raise questions of impartiality. I don’t have much of a problem with it, but can you really expect a sauce maker to rave about someone elses’ stuff at the thought of taking away sales from his own stuff? It’s often hard to leave out mentioning yourself or your products, at least by comparison. If you’re on the board, how do you keep your own opinions out of what makes a ‘quality’ sauce? How do ten folks agree on what the baseline is for it? It can’t be a qulaity sauce, in my opinion and viewpoint, if it contains less than 50% chiles. A lot of folks would agree with that but then just as many, if not more, would not! See? If it’s Joe public (uneducated) than that’s its’ own set of problems. Do you really want someone who knows only a little about food stuff setting the standard? Or someone that thinks Tabasco is the ultimate? If it’s Joe public (educated) then you’re still subject to opinions and tastes. Some like habs, some don’t. Some like chipotle, others hate it. Some think it can’t contain gum, others have no problem with it… and so on.

I DO understand what you’re saying, but in a free market you’re bound to get burnt a time or two. But, you should expect that as you try new things and are experimenting with products you’re not familiar with.

I see nothing in the ingredient list, label, or appearance of the sauce before it is opened that would have disqualified even this one from being able to obtain the same said quality cert. It was only *after* opening and TASTING that this reviewer, in his *opinion* felt it was undeserving.

I never saw your post Tina- I was responding to the review & DD.

Easy Mr Knake :-) I apologize for forgetting the smilies that should have gone into my post. Mus still be hungover from the banquet ;-)

Comment #27:
Comment by Justin (159) - 9/13/2007 @ 11:43 am | [ Quote ]

I know what I like and can read what is on a label. I have my own taste likes and dislikes. I DO NOT NEED THE LIKES OF YOURSELF WHO THINKS YOU CAN BECOME THE CONTROL.

i disliked the version i tried and didnt rate it good, but the only reason i tried it is because it was sent to me to try, reading the label i never would of bought it, so i couldnt agree more. i disagree however with all the comments saying good review on a bad sauce, even though i agree with it not being a good sauce i didnt think it was a good review. yea the ingrediant list makes it hard to tell what you are eating, and what it will taste like, but you shouldnt need that list to describe the taste of it. anyone can read the ingredient list and say thats what it tasted like. i disliked it but rather than go on a rant about it i did my best to describe the flavor and try to pick out wich of the following was actually in it.

Comment #28:
Comment by Tina Brooks (101) - 9/13/2007 @ 12:38 pm | [ Quote ]

Justin… writing a review has two aspects to it. 1) Tell the world what the reviewer thinks of the sauce. 2) Entertain the reader so that he wants to continue reading.

Since Louie did an absolutely stellar job on both these things, it’s a great review.

Sometimes candy-coating a review to be kind to the maker just isn’t on.

(Like I said before, if anyone is going to give ME a bad review, at least be THIS funny!)

T

Comment #29:
Comment by Scott (593) - 9/13/2007 @ 1:07 pm | [ Quote ]

OK, back to the Gotor Poo. What does it smell like?? Ive seen the elusive FL. cooter but what does its poo smell like? Any help would be nice DK. :)

Comment #30:
Comment by Justin (159) - 9/13/2007 @ 1:14 pm | [ Quote ]

yea it was entertaining, and the sauce is bad and deserves what he said about it, but it was just more of a humorus rant than a review.

Comment #31:
Comment by DK (2470) - 9/13/2007 @ 1:48 pm | [ Quote ]

Scott on 9/13/2007 at 1:07 pm said:

OK, back to the Gotor Poo. What does it smell like?? Ive seen the elusive FL. cooter but what does its poo smell like? Any help would be nice DK. :)

I’ll send you a sample Scott. Really hard to describe. It has to experienced. Uncle Big gave me a good tip last night on poo removal, I’ll save what I can for you. ;) :lol:

Hey, I’ve got pictures of the elusive cooter, but i’m still waitin’ on the enquirer to call me back before deciding if I should release them to the public. Only thing, the pictures are kinda fuzzy. :)

Comment #32:
Comment by Tina Brooks (101) - 9/13/2007 @ 3:31 pm | [ Quote ]

Justin on 9/13/2007 at 1:14 pm said:

yea it was entertaining, and the sauce is bad and deserves what he said about it, but it was just more of a humorus rant than a review.

Well, I guess we’ll just have to agree to disagree on that point, then.

I got all the information I expected from a review and more.

You can bet there will only be one of two actions from me when I have the opportunity to pick up this sauce. I will either leave it on the shelf, or, as DK suggested, I will buy it just to see if it’s as bad as Louie found it.

That strikes me as the point of a review. :D

T

Comment #33:
Comment by Justin (159) - 9/13/2007 @ 5:57 pm | [ Quote ]

the only thing these reviews are ment to do is help you decide on whether or not to buy the sauce, and this review definitly did that, it was also funny and entertaining. my original comment wasnt meant to offend or insult anybody, and im sorry if i did. i guess i was just upset that i at 1/4 bottle of this sauce and ruined a good meal to try and figure out what exactly was in it and how to descibe the flavor of it when i could of just said looks smells and tastes like crap 0/10 on everything and then went on a “rant” (his words not mine) about the hot sauce industry and how the government should regulate taste.

Comment #34:
Comment by Justin (159) - 9/13/2007 @ 6:03 pm | [ Quote ]

the only other comment i got about reviews helping to decide if the sauce is worth buying is that the picture of the top of the bottle alone is enough! they say a picture is worth a thousand words, and that picture looks awfull, the x tra hot version didnt look that bad and i Applaud him for even having the courage to try it after seeing that gunked up in the top of the bottle.

Comment #35:
Comment by Devil Duck (68) - 9/14/2007 @ 12:44 am | [ Quote ]

To those of you who replied to me:

I do realize that the logistics of creating a committee would be a nightmare. But, it’s just an idea that I had…so I threw it out there.

Oh…I get jokes!!

-DD-

Comment #36:
Comment by Louie (5) - 9/14/2007 @ 4:31 am | [ Quote ]

Wow. I never thought my review would have created such contoversy. Hey, I told it like I tasted it, and I just hope that maybe I got a sample of a batch gone bad (I realize now that I should have written that in my review, so to Batten Island-my sincere apologies [but read comment #16 again. Way to take it in stride, man]). I wasn’t trying to be funny, but thanks everyone who enjoyed it, I mean that. And especially thanks to Tina would not only had the guts to defend me, but was also smart enough to read between the lines, or for that matter just reading the basic lines. People, for God’s sake, re-read what I wrote. I wrote “..a governing body”, not a GOVERNMENT BODY. Basic Civics class in high school should have told you the difference. Believe me, I am the LAST person who wants the government anywhere it doesn’t need be. I also never told ANYONE what they should like OR dislike. Just where the Hell did you get THAT from? And just where the Hell did you get “the Control” from? What country are we living in? The last time I knew of a “Control”, the word started with a “C”, and ended with the fall of the Berlin Wall. Catch what I’m saying? My suggestion, which I clearly did not articulate enough for those who haven’t mastered basic English composition, was could there be an independent body that DID NOT oversee what would/could be deemed acceptable, but one that would give unofficial, unbiased opinions on sauces based on the simple merits of the ingredients, the handling of the ingredients, and the production of the said ingredients. You say it can’t be done? Don’t tell that to Consumer Reports or Cooks Illustrated magazines, because they think they’ve been doing it for years. Same with the guilds, they’ve been around for CENTURIES, most for the sole purpose of keeping the government out of their crafts. Yes, I know we have the HSB, and let’s keep that the way it is, the way Nick designed and intended it to be. The second-to-last line in my review was, after all, “I don’t know”.And why can’t the manufactors be involved? Isn’t the basis of competition to improve? Hey, let’s be honest here: if you got a bad review on anything, would you not go back to the drawing board and see how you could make what you have better? And what drives the sauce makers? The competition to make the best sauce out there. Re-read what I wrote. I really have no idea why I’m defending myself. I guess I don’t have “The Control” telling me what I should or should not say, only the simple freedoms to be honest with myself and the reviews the HSB asks me to write. Again, thanks to everyone for the support, especially Tina-you’re a real pal. And like I always say: Treat every meal like it was your last!

Comment #37:
Comment by HenryK (217) - 9/14/2007 @ 8:39 am | [ Quote ]

From the extended blog:

Thanks Tina, for writing about my review (Batten Island Gourmet Hot Sauce)! I’m kind of taken aback by the responsences the review received-I wasn’t trying to be funny. I was just writing what happened with that sauce, all in one day. And my review turned to anger because there are sooo many “makers” of “hot sauce”, people who just want to hop on the current hot trend wagon. And what’s worse, I think Batten Island is made by a hot sauce company that is just over-extending it’s product line. I do feel, though, that a standards commitee would be a great idea for not just the established producers, but also the “little guys” that truly have great sauce and do not want to go mass market (like the botique wine makers). Volunteer, to set certain standards for those who know that they’re in this for the product, not the money. True lovers of hot sauce, who want to share their passion with those who know what true hot sauce is. A guild, perhaps? You know what I mean? If you have any ideas that you want to share, please let me know. Again, thanks for the attention, I really do appreciate it. Treat every meal like it was your last, Louie.

Support also comes out in positive reveiews.

Comment #38:
Comment by Louie (5) - 9/14/2007 @ 10:01 am | [ Quote ]

OK, HenryK, I’ll bite:what’s your point? That was sent to Tina days ago.

Comment #39:
Comment by Uncle Big (557) - 9/14/2007 @ 11:56 am | [ Quote ]

Louie on 9/14/2007 at 4:31 am said:

Wow. I never thought my review would have created such contoversy. Hey, I told it like I tasted it, and I just hope that maybe I got a sample of a batch gone bad (I realize now that I should have written that in my review, so to Batten Island-my sincere apologies [but read comment #16 again. Way to take it in stride, man]). I wasn’t trying to be funny, but thanks everyone who enjoyed it, I mean that. And especially thanks to Tina would not only had the guts to defend me, but was also smart enough to read between the lines, or for that matter just reading the basic lines. People, for God’s sake, re-read what I wrote. I wrote “..a governing body”, not a GOVERNMENT BODY. Basic Civics class in high school should have told you the difference. Believe me, I am the LAST person who wants the government anywhere it doesn’t need be. I also never told ANYONE what they should like OR dislike. Just where the Hell did you get THAT from? And just where the Hell did you get “the Control” from? What country are we living in? The last time I knew of a “Control”, the word started with a “C”, and ended with the fall of the Berlin Wall. Catch what I’m saying? My suggestion, which I clearly did not articulate enough for those who haven’t mastered basic English composition, was could there be an independent body that DID NOT oversee what would/could be deemed acceptable, but one that would give unofficial, unbiased opinions on sauces based on the simple merits of the ingredients, the handling of the ingredients, and the production of the said ingredients. You say it can’t be done? Don’t tell that to Consumer Reports or Cooks Illustrated magazines, because they think they’ve been doing it for years. Same with the guilds, they’ve been around for CENTURIES, most for the sole purpose of keeping the government out of their crafts. Yes, I know we have the HSB, and let’s keep that the way it is, the way Nick designed and intended it to be. The second-to-last line in my review was, after all, “I don’t know”.And why can’t the manufactors be involved? Isn’t the basis of competition to improve? Hey, let’s be honest here: if you got a bad review on anything, would you not go back to the drawing board and see how you could make what you have better? And what drives the sauce makers? The competition to make the best sauce out there. Re-read what I wrote. I really have no idea why I’m defending myself. I guess I don’t have “The Control” telling me what I should or should not say, only the simple freedoms to be honest with myself and the reviews the HSB asks me to write. Again, thanks to everyone for the support, especially Tina-you’re a real pal. And like I always say: Treat every meal like it was your last!

Louie,
I don’t think Comment #16 is actually from the maker of this sauce that you poo poo’d.
Actually, I’m almost certain the comment wasn’t made by the maker of this sauce. Trust me. ;)
This was one funny piece of writing though, I will give you that. The cat poop thing was priceless.
Nicely done.

Comment #40:
Comment by Jim Campbell- StepUpForCharity.org (1537) - 9/15/2007 @ 6:35 am | [ Quote ]

Well sir, the admonition to “read” can go both ways ;-) DOGC, as suggested *does* involve the Government, not governance as there are civil and criminal penalties for violation. Essentially all it does is guarantee that the wine you’re drinking comes from the place it says on the label, much like Champagne can only come from that particular region in France. It still does nothing to ensure ‘quality’ as I’ve had my share of swill with the DOGC stamp, and more with the AOC :-)
My original post was more aimed at the suggestion that there needed to be “laws”. I also *didn’t* say that it (certifying ‘guilds’) ‘couldn’t be done’, only that there would be one heck of a lot of problems. We’ll take your example of Consumer Reports. They rate McDonalds as having better coffee than Starbucks. You gonna get widespread agreement with that? Probably not. Free market says definitely not.
My point is still that there is nothing about the sauce reviewed that would have stopped it from getting any certification that might exist, from any group, aside from your *personal opinion* of the taste, upon which you are going to find as many dissenters as agreers.
As one who might be considered ‘ancient’ in this business, I’ve seen several attempts at ‘guilds’ form and vanish under the weight of differeing opinions of taste and quality. Maybe one will eventually take hold and survive, maybe not. I’ve supported all of them as I too have an interest in a level playing field.
I thank you again for the review!

Comment #41:
Comment by Louie (5) - 9/15/2007 @ 1:46 pm | [ Quote ]

Hey Jim,
Thanks for your input, and just so you know, my last post wasn’t aimed at you. Maybe my example of the AOC/DOGC wasn’t correct at what I was trying to say, since they are government regulated. Being a former history teacher, they just both came to mind. But, I should glean more insight from you “ancient” ones, since you’ve seen ore and known more than I. You know its funny, I’ve been using hot sauces for almost 25 years, I’ve been making it for almost 10 years, and until the HSB, I never knew there was such a world out there that shared my passion. There are things out there that I admittedly don’t know about. I guess what I’m trying to say is, thanks for the comments. Take care, and treat every meal like it was your last!

Comment #42:
Comment by Jim Campbell- StepUpForCharity.org (1537) - 9/15/2007 @ 4:59 pm | [ Quote ]

Thanks Louie :-)

At 10 years, you’re an ancient one too ;-)

We *all* thought we were weird before we found others shared our passion ;-)

And, intended or not, you write a very entertaining review :-)

Comment #43:
Comment by Uncle Big (557) - 9/15/2007 @ 6:05 pm | [ Quote ]

Jim Campbell- StepUpForCharity.org on 9/15/2007 at 4:59 pm said:

Thanks Louie :-)

At 10 years, you’re an ancient one too ;-)

We *all* thought we were weird before we found others shared our passion ;-)

And, intended or not, you write a very entertaining review :-)

Jim are you making fun of me because of “old school HSOTM” comments?
You’re not ancient, you’re still active and relevant in the community and in a huge way.
Other makers, who will remain flavourless, er I mean nameless are whom I was referring.
You’re the man Jim, justified, but not ancient.

Comment #44:
Comment by Uncle Big (557) - 9/15/2007 @ 6:07 pm | [ Quote ]

Louie on 9/15/2007 at 1:46 pm said:

Hey Jim,
Thanks for your input, and just so you know, my last post wasn’t aimed at you. Maybe my example of the AOC/DOGC wasn’t correct at what I was trying to say, since they are government regulated. Being a former history teacher, they just both came to mind. But, I should glean more insight from you “ancient” ones, since you’ve seen ore and known more than I. You know its funny, I’ve been using hot sauces for almost 25 years, I’ve been making it for almost 10 years, and until the HSB, I never knew there was such a world out there that shared my passion. There are things out there that I admittedly don’t know about. I guess what I’m trying to say is, thanks for the comments. Take care, and treat every meal like it was your last!

Louie,
You’re a weirdo just like the rest of the millions and millions of fiery food lovers out there, and that includes me. I think we’re in good company.
I hope the wife and the two little ones are well, thanks for the email.

Comment #45:
Comment by Tina Brooks (101) - 9/15/2007 @ 6:17 pm | [ Quote ]

Say Big (have your feet touched the ground yet and do you still remember what it was like to sleep through the night??)… I’m only waiting on the mailing address where you want me to send your samples.

(And that is a one man offer of samples, so don’t everyone write me asking where theirs are).

T

Comment #46:
Comment by Jim Campbell- StepUpForCharity.org (1537) - 9/15/2007 @ 6:19 pm | [ Quote ]

UB- as I’ve said before, I might run into burning buildings for a living but I ain’t *dumb*- no way I’d make fun of you :-) Discretion being the better part of valour and all that, not to mention “yield to mass” ;-)

Catchin’ any sleep yet or do you still have that ‘new dad haggard’ look?

Comment #47:
Comment by Uncle Big (557) - 9/15/2007 @ 6:43 pm | [ Quote ]

Tina Brooks on 9/15/2007 at 6:17 pm said:

Say Big (have your feet touched the ground yet and do you still remember what it was like to sleep through the night??)… I’m only waiting on the mailing address where you want me to send your samples.

(And that is a one man offer of samples, so don’t everyone write me asking where theirs are).

T

Tina,
My feet have been dragging the last couple of days.
I don’t know how women do it, well I know how they do it as far as the whole birthing process, I had my eyes open during that, it’s just the after care.
The lack of sleep and constant milk production is something to behold.
I have a new respect for mothers.
I’ll shoot you an email when I get home.

Comment #48:
Comment by Uncle Big (557) - 9/15/2007 @ 6:45 pm | [ Quote ]

Jim Campbell- StepUpForCharity.org on 9/15/2007 at 6:19 pm said:

UB- as I’ve said before, I might run into burning buildings for a living but I ain’t *dumb*- no way I’d make fun of you :-) Discretion being the better part of valour and all that, not to mention “yield to mass” ;-)

Catchin’ any sleep yet or do you still have that ‘new dad haggard’ look?

Ah Jim, I’m just pulling your fire hose.
Yeah, I’ve got the sunken eye heroin sheik look going, minus the weight loss of course.
I look like 20 miles of bad road, but it’s all worth it. Right? Can I get an amen?
Speaking of, I need to get home and help out with the bambino.
Peace out people.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>
Smilies - HSB Rules & Regs - Spamtastic?

(required)

(required)



Copyright © 2004-2007 Hot Sauce Blog - Design by Moxie
BioCap - Revolutionary Anti-Wrinkle Cream - Pink Floyd Lyrics